Public release date: 12-Oct-2011
New buzzwords ‘reduce medicine to economics’
BIDMC physicians lament the devaluation of clinical judgment in today’s health care world
BOSTON – Physicians who once only grappled with learning the language of medicine must now also cope with a health care world that has turned hospitals into factories and reduced clinical encounters to economic transactions, two Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center physicians lament.
“Patients are no longer patients, but rather ‘customers’ or ‘consumers’. Doctors and nurses have transmuted into ‘providers,’ Pamela Hartzband, MD and Jerome Groopman MD, write in the Oct. 13 edition of the New England Journal of Medicine.
“We are in the midst of an economic crisis and efforts to reform the health care system have centered on controlling spiraling costs. To that end, many economists and policy makers have proposed that patient care should be industrialized and standardized. Hospitals and clinics should be run like modern factories and archaic terms like doctor, nurse and patient must therefore be replaced with terminology that fits this new order.”
The problem, Hartzband and Groopman, note, is that the special knowledge that doctors and nurses possess and use to help patients understand the reason for and remedies to their illness get lost in a system that values prepackaged, off-the-shelf solutions that substitute “evidence-based practice” for “clinical judgment.”
“Reducing medicine to economics makes a mockery of the bond between the healer and the sick,” they write. “For centuries doctors who were mercenary were publicly and appropriately castigated … Such doctors betrayed their calling. Should we now be celebrating the doctor whose practice, like a successful business, maximizes profits from ‘customers’”?
Hartzband and Groopman say the new emphasis on “evidence-based practice” is not really a new phenomenon at all. “Evidence” was routinely presented on daily rounds or clinical conferences where doctors debated numerous research studies.
“But the exercise of clinical judgment, which permitted the assessment of those data and the application of study results to an individual patient, was seen as the acme of professional practice. Now some prominent health policy planners and even physicians contend that clinical care should essentially be a matter of following operating manuals containing preset guidelines, like factory blueprints, written by experts.”
They note the subjective core of the concept is proven by the fact that working with the same data, different groups of experts often write different guidelines for conditions as common as hypertension and elevated cholesterol levels or for the use of screening tests for prostate and breast cancer.
“The specific cutoffs for treatment or no treatment … all necessarily reflect the values and preferences of the experts who write the recommendations. And these values and preferences are subjective, not scientific.”
Even more troubling, the authors suggest, is the impact of the new vocabulary on future doctors, nurses, therapists and social workers who care for patients.
“Recasting their roles as providers who merely implement prefabricated practices diminishes their professionalism. Reconfiguring medicine in economic and industrial terms is unlikely to attract creative and independent thinkers with not only expertise in science and biology but also an authentic focus on humanism and caring.
“When we ourselves are ill, we want someone to care about us as people, not paying customers and to individualize our treatment according to our values. Despite the lip service paid to ‘patient-centered care’ by the forces promulgating the new language of medicine, their discourse shifts the focus from the good of the individual to the exigencies of the system and its costs.
“We believe doctors, nurses and others engaged in care should eschew the use of such terms that demean patients and professionals alike and dangerously neglect the essence of medicine.”
- Physicians suggest expert recommendations ignore vital issues for patients (eurekalert.org)
- New buzzwords ‘reduce medicine to economics’ (eurekalert.org)
- New buzzwords ‘reduce medicine to economics’ (esciencenews.com)
- Doctors Speak: Healthcare Reduced to Profiteering (habwwe.wordpress.com)
- Doctor and Patient or Provider and Consumer? (blogs.wsj.com)